Arena Pantanal, the soccer stadium created in Cuiaba, is almost ready to open. Although this arena is not a direct threat to its namesake, it's interesting to analyze it in a larger social context. Over the past six months, over a million Brazilians have protested the amount of money spent in preparation for the World Cup. The anger is due to the spending being double the budget, and that the extra money came from funds reserved for education, healthcare, and public transportation. The excess money used on security and new facilities could have been used to help alleviate the large social inequality that exists in Brazil. Bringing this back to the Pantanal, instead of honoring the stadium with its name, a less extravagant facility could have been built, with the extra money being spend directly on conservation efforts, or to help the poor in the region so that there is less tension between human resource need and protection of the Pantanal. Not to mention that it would probably help decrease the occurrence of poaching. People argue that the World Cup is a good thing for Brazil and can serve as an opportunity to demonstrate to the world what Brazil has to offer. If this were actually true, maybe less money should be spent on new facilities for tourists, and more on the people and environment that make it special.
-Catie
The anger in Brazil is certainly worrying. Anecdotally, I met a group of Brazilians while travelling this summer, and when I brought up the World Cup they were uniformly negative about hosting it. Considering the funding and organisation mismanagement, it remains to be seen whether the environmental aspects can be handled adequately.
ReplyDeleteThe irony of naming the stadium after the Pantanal when really conservation funds are being used to promote the World Cup is startling and upsetting. I'm glad to hear that some Brazilians don't approve of this, but I wonder if it is too late- after all, the World Cup is in July, and many arrangements- including this stadium- have already been made. It seems like there's a big disconnect between the people who manage Brazil's World Cup funds, and the people whose taxes are levied to pay for it. I don't think the controversy around World Cup will solve it, but I do think it will make people more aware of this contradiction and maybe inspire them to do something about it in the future.
ReplyDelete